Suicide Thoughts VS. Stoic Reflections on Death as Limitation, Melancholy, and the Dark Night – Four Perspectives on Death

-
The thought of death reveals itself in very different contexts— from philosophical reflection, through emotional crisis, to spiritual transcendence. This timeless post introduces four distinct perspectives: stoic reflection, suicidal thoughts arising from crisis or depression, poetic melancholy, and finally the mystical experience of the Dark Night of the Soul. The aim is not just rational clarity but also possible paths to hope—especially through the contemplative way outlined by John of the Cross.

1. Stoic Reflection on Death

In stoic thought, death is not an enemy but a prompt to live meaningfully. Marcus Aurelius puts it pointedly:

“It is not death that a man should fear, but he should fear never beginning to live.”

If we reflect that both the longest-lived and shortest-lived person give up the same thing— the present moment—then the point becomes clear:

“When the longest-lived and
the shortest-lived man,
when they come to die,
their loss is precisely equal. 
For the sole thing of which any man 
can be deprived is the present; 
since this is all he owns, 
and nobody can lose what is not his.”
(Meditations 2.14)

Marcus further emphasizes:

“Do not act as if you were going to live ten thousand years. Death hangs over you. While you live… be good.”

Stoic reflection on impermanence gives us clarity: begin to live now. Set priorities. Fear of death often masks fear of not truly living. 

2. Suicidal Thoughts in Crisis and Depression

When people think of death after profound loss—like a breakup, job loss, or illness—it is often a reaction to acute crisis, not a sign of clinical depression. Here, despair can trigger escape fantasies rather than a desire to end life itself.

Yet, in prolonged suffering—whether physical or psychological—suicidal thoughts may emerge because life feels unbearable. Professional help becomes essential in such cases. This section is explicitly distinguished from the Dark Night, which is spiritual and non-pathological.


3. Melancholy—Poetic Longing for Death

Melancholy is often mistaken for clinical depression but tends to be reflective and even aesthetic:

  • A longing for depth and transcendence, not necessarily for death.
  • It can be creative, poetic, spiritual.
Romano Guardini describes this mood as 

“the disturbance of man
by the proximity of the eternal.”

Melancholy lies between being alive and death thoughts; it's sensitive and vulnerable, but not necessarily pathological. It brushes against the eternal without fully articulating it—unlike the Dark Night, which is consciously transformational.

4. The Dark Night of the Soul—John of the Cross 

This is about the mystical experience of spiritual emptiness that leads to the only source of divine union—possible during one’s lifetime.

John of the Cross distinguishes two purifying nights:


I. The first night of the senses—detachment from sensory desires.

II. The second night of the spirit—a deeper purification, even from spiritual consolation, culminating in mystical union. This transition is included in his commentary "Dark Night." We treat these stages in a specific episode. 

Contemplation in the sense of the second night is not passive meditation—it is purification through darkness, a subtle quality beyond earlier spiritual experiences:

  • The soul loses imagery, control, and certainties.
  • A spiritual path where only the subtle presence of God remains

“The endurance of darkness is preparation for great light.” – John of the Cross

This quote precisely expresses what is needed: in the deepest abandonment, seeds of light, courage, and profound comfort are hidden—even when nothing else seems to work.

Another powerful image comes from the well-known “Happy Night” stanza:

“Oh, happy chance… This light guided me more surely than the light of noonday… Oh, night that joined Beloved with lover, Lover transformed in the Beloved!”

This passage conveys that darkness is not loss, but the gateway to union—a light attainable during one’s lifetime, not sentimental but existentially real.

Picture: thanks to Teena Lalawat on Unsplash

Danger of Confusing with Suicide

Those who believe they can only be united with God in death—viewing heaven purely as a post-mortem destination—risk rationalizing suicide as a spiritual act. John of the Cross, however, teaches that union with God is possible now, in the here and now, by passing through the Dark Night—without ending one’s life, but by embracing life more deeply.

Conclusion: 

Four Pathways, One Spiritual Journey
Philosophical reflection, emotional crisis, poetic melancholy, and spiritual transformation—these may appear similar outwardly, but they carry different significance:

  • Stoic reflection urges meaningful living.
  • Crisis and depression call for support and care.
  • Melancholy can nurture artistic depth.
  • The Dark Night is a spiritual path toward contemplation and divine presence in life.

In the best case scenario, death is not an end but a teacher—and the Dark Night is not a suicidal trap, but a gift: a narrow path toward inner clarity, a light that shines more deeply than any previous experience.

Key Bibliography

Guardini, Romano (1961). The End of the Modern World and Other Essays. Longmans, Green & Co.

John of the Cross. (1991). The Collected Works of St. John of the Cross (K. Kavanaugh & O. Rodriguez, Trans.). ICS Publications. (Original work published 1584–86)

Marcus Aurelius. (1997). Meditations (M. Hays, Trans.). Modern Library. (Original work published ca. 175 CE) 

Authored by Rebekka Waldesruh

Social Media:
Categories:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Guilt and the Dark Night of the Soul: Between Deep Spiritual Crisis and Everyday Life

-
Image
Most of us are familiar with guilt. We feel responsible for things beyond our control, or we believe we’ve done something wrong, even when, objectively, we haven’t. This type of guilt, arising from upbringing, societal expectations, or old childhood patterns, is conditioned . It weighs on us without us actually being “guilty” in a moral or spiritual sense. Social and Conditioned Guilt in Everyday Life Many people experience this type of guilt daily: a mother feels responsible when her children argue, even though she’s not involved in the conflict. A colleague believes they caused a project to fail, even though external circumstances were decisive. Such feelings are internalized expectations —social and cultural conditioning that can accompany us throughout our lives. Historically, churches and religious institutions have also contributed to a sense of false guilt . Strict moral rules, dogmas, and sermons often created pressure designed to control people. The result: we are accustome...
Open Episode »

The Sacred Value of Being Alone: Solitude in the Dark Night of the Soul

-
Image
1. A Hidden Longing in a Loud World In an age of hyperconnectivity, constant stimulation, and perpetual exposure to noise—both literal and digital—many people find themselves unexpectedly longing for solitude. It’s not necessarily because they dislike others, but because they can no longer hear themselves. The internal voice becomes drowned out by the noise of productivity, messaging apps, and the endless presence of other people’s expectations. This longing for aloneness becomes even more noticeable among people who engage in spiritual practices like prayer, meditation, or contemplation. Sometimes, without any obvious reason, a quiet but firm inner pull arises: Step away . Be still . Be alone . Far from being a retreat from life, this movement toward solitude may in fact be the soul's instinctive response to a deeper transformation at work. For the Christian mystic John of the Cross, aloneness is not an escape but a necessary condition for inner purification. Especially in what...
Open Episode »