The Quiet Self-Deception of Spiritual People — Why John of the Cross Is More Relevant Than Ever

The longer you spend around spiritual people, the more you begin to notice a pattern.

There are the obvious cases: people who claim to be enlightened, to have reached a higher level of consciousness, or to have a uniquely direct relationship with God. These cases are easy to recognize. Even within spiritual circles, people tend to see them as signs of spiritual arrogance or self-deception.

But they are not the most interesting cases.

The more subtle form of self-deception is much harder to recognize.

It can be found among ordinary religious Christians as well as among spiritual seekers who do not identify with any particular religion. These people usually do not claim to be perfect. They do not walk around declaring themselves enlightened.

Instead, they say things like:

“I live with God.”

“I am being guided.”

“I have found peace.”

“Everything flows.”

And they may genuinely mean it.

Yet there is an important question we should ask:

If this is already a permanent union with God, why does it keep disappearing?

Why do periods of peace alternate with anxiety, frustration, confusion, spiritual dryness, doubt, or inner turmoil?

And why, when those difficult periods arrive, do we immediately start looking for something to fix them?

We pray more.

We meditate more.

We read another book.

We search for another teacher.

We try another technique.

Perhaps the problem is not that we have failed to become spiritual enough.

Perhaps we have mistaken the path for the destination.

Spiritual experiences are not the same as spiritual realization

The human mind naturally moves through fluctuations.

Emotions rise and fall. Motivation changes. Clarity gives way to confusion and returns again. Even religious experience can fluctuate enormously.

There may be periods when prayer feels effortless and deeply meaningful, followed by days when prayer feels completely empty.

Meditation may suddenly become peaceful and profound — and the next day it may feel impossible.

None of this is necessarily a problem.

It is part of ordinary human experience.

The problem begins when we mistake these temporary experiences for permanent transformation.

A powerful spiritual experience is not necessarily lasting realization.

A moment of profound peace is not necessarily freedom.

Feeling close to God does not necessarily mean that the underlying sense of separation has disappeared.

This is precisely where John of the Cross offers an insight that remains remarkably relevant today.

Picture: Luis Morera on Unsplash

The real provocation of John of the Cross

Most people have heard of the “Dark Night of the Soul.”

It is often understood as a particularly difficult period in life — a spiritual crisis, a loss of faith, or a period in which God seems absent.

But John of the Cross is describing something much more radical.

In his view, people who are seriously engaged in the spiritual life can already be in a form of the Dark Night without even realizing it.

They believe they are growing closer to God.

They believe their spirituality is becoming more mature.

Yet they are still dependent on countless inner supports.

In the sixteenth century, these might have included particular forms of prayer, devotional practices, religious experiences, or spiritual exercises.

Today, the objects may look very different.

We may become attached to meditation techniques.

To particular spiritual teachers.

To books.

To retreats.

To symbols.

To crystals.

To rituals.

To theological concepts.

To psychological frameworks.

Or even to the identity of being a “spiritual person.”

None of these things is necessarily bad.

The problem is not that they exist.

The problem is attachment.

And this is one of John of the Cross's most important insights: even something genuinely good can become an obstacle when we begin to depend on it as a source of spiritual security.

The real obstacle lies deeper than the symptoms

This is where John of the Cross is particularly easy to misunderstand.

Most people see the problem in the symptoms.

“I can't meditate anymore.”

“I don't feel God anymore.”

“My prayers feel empty.”

“My spiritual practice isn't working.”

But these may not be the causes.

They may already be the consequences.

The deeper problem is what we have unconsciously come to depend upon.

We develop ideas about what God should be like.

What spirituality should feel like.

What peace should feel like.

What prayer should accomplish.

What enlightenment should look like.

And then something happens: those expectations begin to collapse.

The crisis is not necessarily caused by God disappearing.

It may be caused by our own image of God disappearing.

That distinction changes everything.

What feels like spiritual failure may actually be the beginning of a deeper transformation.

Purification does not mean condemning yourself

This is particularly important for modern readers.

Words such as purification, asceticism, or detachment can easily sound oppressive today.

They can evoke guilt, self-denial, excessive self-criticism, or religious perfectionism.

But that is not the point.

John of the Cross is not asking us to constantly attack ourselves.

He is not asking us to obsess over every imperfection.

Purification does not mean sitting there thinking:

“What is wrong with me?”

The more useful question is:

“What am I still holding on to?”

That is a completely different approach.

Purification is not self-punishment.

It is the gradual release of the things we have turned into sources of security.

Not because those things are necessarily evil.

But because even good things can become substitutes for God when we become attached to them.

The modern spiritual marketplace

This may be one reason John of the Cross feels surprisingly contemporary.

In his time, most people lived within a relatively stable religious world.

Today, spirituality exists in an enormous marketplace.

Christianity.

Buddhism.

Advaita.

Mindfulness.

Yoga.

Shamanism.

Psychology.

Neuroscience.

Meditation.

There seem to be endless paths available.

And yet the underlying human tendency remains the same.

We can leave one identification only to immediately replace it with another.

We reject one religious system and become attached to another worldview.

We leave the church and become devoted to a spiritual teacher.

We reject dogma and become dogmatic about non-dogmatism.

We move away from traditional religion and construct a new spiritual identity around our favorite books, practices, concepts, or experiences.

The external forms change.

The attachment does not.

This is why John of the Cross can still speak to people who would never describe themselves as traditional Christians.

His analysis is not fundamentally about which spiritual objects we choose.

It is about what happens when we cling to them.

The uncomfortable truth

Perhaps this is the real message of the Dark Night.

Most people think of it as an exception.

John of the Cross treats it as part of the normal spiritual journey.

Most people believe that becoming more spiritual means experiencing more and more peace.

John asks whether we might instead have to let go of our dependence on peace itself.

Most people look for better methods.

John asks whether our constant search for methods has itself become an obstacle.

Most people want to preserve their spiritual experiences.

John points toward a freedom in which even those experiences cannot become objects of attachment.

This is uncomfortable.

Because it means that the very things we consider to be evidence of our spirituality may sometimes be the things preventing its fulfillment.

The obvious cases are not the real problem

This also brings us back to the people who openly claim enlightenment.

They are easy to criticize.

Someone who constantly announces that they are enlightened is an obvious example of spiritual self-deception.

But the much more interesting question is whether a quieter version of the same mechanism exists within ourselves.

Perhaps we do not say:

“I am enlightened.”

Perhaps we simply assume:

“I already live with God.”

And then, whenever our inner state changes, we try to restore the feeling we had before.

That is much subtler.

And precisely because it looks ordinary, it can remain unnoticed for years.

The issue is not whether we are allowed to experience joy, peace, spiritual consolation, or a sense of God's presence.

Of course we are.

The issue is whether we have mistaken these experiences for the final destination.

A message that reaches beyond Christianity

John of the Cross was a Christian mystic, and his writings are deeply rooted in Christian theology.

There is no need to erase that context.

At the same time, his analysis of attachment, spiritual identity, expectation, and inner transformation can speak to people far beyond traditional Christianity.

A person does not have to reject the Church in order to recognize this.

Nor does a person have to become religious.

In fact, one of the paradoxes of genuine spiritual development may be that the further one progresses, the less one needs to define oneself through opposition to other traditions.

The question eventually becomes less:

“Which spiritual system is correct?”

and more:

“What am I still clinging to?”

That question can be asked by a Christian.

It can be asked by a Buddhist.

It can be asked by someone who follows no religion at all.

And perhaps that is one reason the writings of John of the Cross continue to have something to say to the modern spiritual seeker.

The Dark Night is not the end

The Dark Night is therefore not simply a story about feeling bad.

It is not a psychological trick for explaining depression.

And it is not a demand to become increasingly hard on yourself.

It is a description of a process in which the supports on which our spiritual identity depends gradually lose their power.

At first, this can feel like loss.

Later, it may be recognized as freedom.

What disappears is not necessarily spirituality itself.

What disappears is our dependence on the particular forms through which we expected spirituality to reach us.

And this is where John of the Cross becomes even more radical.

Because the Dark Night is not ultimately about remaining in darkness.

It is about what becomes possible when we no longer mistake our concepts, experiences, practices, or identities for God himself.

John of the Cross ultimately speaks of union with God — the Unio Mystica — and uses language that can sound surprisingly close to what other traditions call enlightenment.

What exactly did he mean by this?

And why did a sixteenth-century Christian mystic use language that can be meaningfully compared with concepts of awakening and enlightenment found in other traditions?

That question deserves its own discussion.

For now, perhaps it is enough to recognize the first and most uncomfortable step:

The greatest obstacle to spiritual transformation may not be that we have too little spirituality — but that we are still attached to the spirituality we already have.


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Guilt, Conditioning, and the Dark Night of the Soul

Dark Night of the Soul Symptoms: Common Inner Experiences

The Sacred Value of Being Alone: Solitude in the Dark Night of the Soul