High Sensitivity and the Dark Night of the Soul

When heightened sensitivity meets an ancient language of transformation

Some people seem to move through the world with the volume turned slightly higher.

A conversation can linger long after it has ended. A change in atmosphere may be noticed before anyone says that something feels different. Music, beauty, conflict, other people's emotions, or even apparently insignificant impressions can take time to settle. What others experience and leave behind may continue to unfold inwardly.

Today, many people would describe such an experience as being highly sensitive.

Psychology has given this experience a more precise name: sensory processing sensitivity, or SPS. It is not a diagnosis, nor does it simply mean that someone's senses are unusually sharp. Research describes it as a trait involving, among other things, deeper processing of information, emotional reactivity, sensitivity to subtle stimuli, and a greater tendency to become overwhelmed by excessive stimulation. At the same time, researchers continue to debate precisely how these different aspects belong together and what mechanisms underlie the trait.

There is another language, much older than the psychological vocabulary of sensitivity.

John of the Cross wrote about a different kind of intensity: the experience of being led through a dark night in which familiar forms of spiritual consolation gradually cease to provide the support they once did.

It is tempting to put these two ideas together.

Perhaps highly sensitive people experience the Dark Night more intensely. Perhaps their openness makes them particularly receptive to spiritual transformation. Perhaps what psychology calls sensitivity is part of what mystics once described in other words.

But such conclusions would be too quick.

The relationship between sensitivity and the Dark Night is much more interesting when we resist the temptation to make them identical.


What does “high sensitivity” actually mean?

The expression highly sensitive person is now widely used, but popular descriptions can make the concept sound simpler than the research allows.

In psychological research, the more precise term is sensory processing sensitivity (SPS). SPS is understood as an individual-difference trait rather than a disorder. People vary along a continuum rather than falling neatly into two groups of “sensitive” and “non-sensitive.”

The trait is commonly associated with deeper processing of information, emotional responsiveness, awareness of subtle differences, and susceptibility to overstimulation. But this does not mean that a highly sensitive person necessarily sees, hears, or otherwise detects objectively weaker physical stimuli than everyone else.

That distinction matters.

A person may experience an environment as intensely stimulating without possessing unusually sensitive sensory receptors. Sensitivity involves how experience is processed and experienced, not simply how much physical information reaches the senses.

Recent research has made this distinction increasingly important. A 2026 review describes SPS as an established area of research while also pointing to unresolved questions about its underlying mechanisms and the precise relationships among its different components.

So when we speak about sensitivity in the context of spirituality, we should not imagine a kind of biological superpower.

Nor should we imagine a weakness.

Sensitivity is better understood as a particular way in which a person may encounter and process experience.

And that way of encountering the world can have more than one consequence.


Sensitivity is not simply a burden

There is a tendency to describe high sensitivity in one of two ways.

Either it becomes a problem: overstimulation, exhaustion, emotional overwhelm, the need to withdraw.

Or it becomes a gift: greater empathy, greater depth, greater creativity, greater spiritual awareness.

Both descriptions contain something recognizable. Neither is sufficient on its own.

Research on environmental sensitivity has increasingly emphasized that people can differ in how strongly they respond to their surroundings. Greater sensitivity may make difficult environments more challenging, but it can also be associated with greater benefit under supportive conditions.

Pic: Magnus Andersson on Unsplash

In other words, sensitivity does not determine the meaning of an experience.

It may influence how strongly a person responds to the conditions in which that experience occurs.

That is a much more modest claim — but perhaps a more useful one.

It also prevents us from turning sensitivity into an identity hierarchy.

Being highly sensitive does not make someone more spiritually advanced. It does not make every intense feeling meaningful. It does not mean that every painful experience is an invitation to transformation.

Sometimes overstimulation is simply overstimulation.

Sometimes sadness is simply sadness.

And sometimes an experience that feels spiritually significant may still require psychological, medical, or social attention.

This becomes especially important when we bring the Dark Night into the conversation.


What happens when spirituality enters the picture?

Interestingly, research has begun to investigate whether sensory processing sensitivity is related to spirituality and religiosity.

A 2024 study of two large Czech samples, comprising almost 3,000 adults altogether, found associations between higher SPS scores and several dimensions of self-reported religiosity and spirituality. Higher SPS was associated with a greater likelihood of describing oneself as religious or spiritual, while no significant association was found with regular religious attendance.

This is an intriguing finding.

But it does not tell us that highly sensitive people are more mystical.

It does not tell us that they experience the Dark Night more frequently.

And it certainly does not establish that sensitivity causes spiritual development.

The study was concerned with religiosity and spirituality as measured by questionnaires, not with mystical transformation in the sense described by John of the Cross.

That distinction is easy to lose when psychological and spiritual vocabulary begin to overlap.

Spirituality is a broad category.

Mystical experience is narrower.

And the Dark Night of John of the Cross is narrower still.


Beyond ordinary experience

Another line of research may be relevant, although it needs even more caution.

A 2024 study examined SPS alongside concepts such as transliminality and boundary thinness, and their relationships with what the researchers call anomalous experiences and beliefs. The study found correlations between these variables, but when the different traits were considered together, transliminality and boundary thinness helped account for relationships that might otherwise simply have been attributed to SPS. In particular, transliminality predicted anomalous experiences and abilities more strongly than SPS itself.

This does not prove anything about mystical experience.

The term anomalous experience is itself a research category covering experiences that depart from ordinary experience or from commonly accepted explanations. It includes a wide range of phenomena and should not simply be equated with religious or mystical experience.

Still, the finding raises an interesting possibility.

Perhaps what we casually call “spiritual sensitivity” is not one single capacity.

It may involve several partially overlapping characteristics: attention to subtle experience, emotional responsiveness, absorption, permeability between inner and outer experience, and particular ways of processing meaning.

SPS may be one piece of that picture.

It may not be the whole picture.

And this is precisely where the ancient language of the Dark Night needs to remain distinct.


John of the Cross was not describing high sensitivity

John of the Cross did not have a psychological theory of sensory processing sensitivity.

He was not describing highly sensitive people in modern terms.

His Dark Night of the Soul belongs to a theological and mystical framework in which the human person is being transformed in relation to God. The “night” is not primarily a description of a sensitive nervous system. Nor is the night of the senses simply a poetic name for sensory overstimulation.

This distinction is essential.

John describes the first night as a purgation in which the forms of spiritual nourishment and consolation upon which a person has relied cease to function in their familiar way. Meditation becomes difficult. Former pleasures in spiritual exercises disappear. The person may experience dryness, darkness, and an inability to proceed as before.

The point is not that the person suddenly perceives too much.

In an important sense, the problem is almost the opposite.

What once provided recognizable spiritual experience no longer does so.

The familiar way of experiencing God is being withdrawn.

That is a very different proposition from heightened sensitivity.


The “night of the senses” is not the same as sensory sensitivity

The modern word sensory can easily mislead us here.

When we hear sensory processing, we naturally think about sights, sounds, touch, physical stimulation, and the nervous system.

John's “night of the senses” belongs to a different conceptual world.

His concern is the sensual part of the person in relation to spiritual transformation. The senses, imagination, meditation, and other faculties have become accustomed to receiving a certain kind of spiritual nourishment. In the night, that familiar mode of receiving is gradually interrupted.

This is why simply translating John's language into modern psychology does not work.

And John himself provides another reason for caution.

He explicitly warns that spiritual dryness can have many causes. It may arise from imperfections, weakness, lukewarmness, or physical indisposition rather than from the spiritual purgation he is describing. He therefore offers criteria for distinguishing the Dark Night from other forms of dryness.

That is a remarkably important point for anyone trying to connect his work with contemporary experiences.

Not every darkness is the Dark Night.

And not every intense experience of a highly sensitive person is evidence of spiritual transformation.


Then why do the two sometimes seem to speak to each other?

Because there can still be a genuine point of resonance.

A highly sensitive person may already be accustomed to noticing subtle shifts in emotion, atmosphere, relationships, bodily states, or inner experience.

When familiar spiritual structures begin to change, that person may notice the change very acutely.

But this is a hypothesis about the subjective texture of an experience, not a conclusion about its spiritual meaning.

Imagine two people sitting in the same dark room.

One may notice very little at first.

The other may notice the temperature changing, the sound of distant traffic, the movement of air, the tension in their body, and the subtle emotional atmosphere.

The darkness itself has not necessarily become different.

Their experience of it has.

This is perhaps the most useful way to think about sensitivity in relation to the Dark Night.

SPS might influence how an experience is received without determining what the experience means.

That distinction allows us to take both psychology and mysticism seriously.


Sensitivity does not make someone spiritually deeper

There is another temptation worth resisting.

If sensitivity is associated with deeper processing, empathy, spirituality, and unusual experiences, it is easy to construct a flattering narrative:

I feel more deeply.
Therefore I perceive more deeply.
Therefore I understand more deeply.
Therefore my suffering is spiritually significant.

But none of those steps follows automatically.

Sensitivity can make a person more aware of an experience without making the person's interpretation of that experience more accurate.

A highly sensitive person can misinterpret an experience.

A less sensitive person can understand something profound.

Spiritual depth cannot be measured by intensity of feeling.

This matters particularly in spiritual crises, because the desire to find meaning in suffering can itself become another way of holding onto an experience.

The Dark Night, in John's understanding, is not an invitation to become fascinated with one's own inner life.

It is, in part, a movement away from reliance on precisely those familiar forms of experience.


A curious convergence

And yet, there is something striking here.

Modern psychology and John of the Cross begin from very different places, but both can make us question the assumption that more intense experience automatically means more truth.

Psychology asks us to examine how individual differences shape perception, emotion, attention, and processing.

John asks what happens when even cherished spiritual experiences cease to function as sources of certainty and consolation.

Neither framework allows us to conclude simply:

“I experienced something intensely, therefore it must be true.”

That may be one of the most useful meeting points between the two traditions.

Sensitivity may make the inner world vivid.

The Dark Night, however, is not about making the inner world ever more vivid.

It is about what happens when the familiar ways of grasping and receiving spiritual experience no longer suffice.


Could sensitivity affect a Dark Night?

This is where we reach the boundary of what we currently know.

There is research connecting SPS with spirituality and religiosity. There is research connecting SPS with several forms of unusual or anomalous experience. There is substantial research examining SPS itself and its relationship to emotional processing, overstimulation, environmental conditions, and mental health.

But this is not the same as research on SPS and the Dark Night of the Soul.

At present, we should therefore be careful with statements such as:

Highly sensitive people experience the Dark Night more intensely.

Or:

Highly sensitive people are especially suited to mystical transformation.

Those statements may sound intuitively plausible.

They are not established conclusions.

A more interesting question would be an empirical one:

If people with different levels of sensory processing sensitivity undergo experiences they themselves understand as spiritual crisis or Dark Night, do they differ in the subjective texture, duration, triggers, coping strategies, or interpretation of those experiences?

That is a question research could actually investigate.

It would also require considerable conceptual care. A study would first have to distinguish spiritual crisis from depression, anxiety, trauma, grief, ordinary religious doubt, burnout, and other forms of distress. It would need to distinguish mystical experience from general unusual experience. And it would have to take seriously the fact that “Dark Night” is not simply a psychological symptom category.

Perhaps that is why the question remains so open.

The two vocabularies were developed for different purposes.

On the question if sensitivity can affect the Dark Night we have a separate episode.


What sensitivity can — and cannot — tell us

Perhaps, then, sensitivity is best understood neither as a spiritual gift nor as a spiritual liability.

It is a way of describing certain individual differences in how experience is processed.

For someone walking through a spiritual crisis, that may matter.

A person who is easily overwhelmed may need more periods of quiet.

A person who processes experiences deeply may need more time before an event settles.

A person who is highly emotionally responsive may experience relational changes with considerable force.

And a person who is accustomed to noticing subtle inner movements may become very aware when familiar patterns of prayer, meditation, meaning, or consolation begin to change.

None of this tells us what those changes ultimately mean.

That question belongs to another level of inquiry.

And here John's work remains valuable precisely because it refuses to reduce everything to intensity.

For him, the Dark Night is not simply about feeling more.

It is about being gradually detached from familiar ways of possessing, understanding, and taking consolation in the spiritual life.

The experience may be dark.

But darkness, by itself, is not the definition.


Perhaps sensitivity is not the answer, but part of the question

There is something appealing about the idea that highly sensitive people might have a special relationship with the Dark Night.

It offers an explanation for why certain experiences can feel so overwhelming, why spiritual changes may be noticed so acutely, and why some people are drawn toward contemplative questions in the first place.

Research gives us some reason to take parts of that intuition seriously. SPS is associated with spirituality and religiosity in contemporary samples, and it overlaps in interesting ways with other traits associated with unusual experience.

But research does not give us permission to turn sensitivity into destiny.

And John of the Cross does not give us permission to turn every experience of darkness into a mystical passage.

Perhaps the most honest position lies between those two temptations.

Sensitivity may shape the way a person receives an experience.

It does not, by itself, determine what that experience is.

And the Dark Night cannot be reduced to a particular psychological temperament.

The interesting question is therefore not whether highly sensitive people are somehow destined for the Dark Night.

It is what happens when a person who already encounters the world with unusual depth enters a process in which even familiar ways of experiencing the spiritual world begin to fall silent.

That question remains largely open.

And perhaps that openness is worth preserving.

Because sometimes the most fruitful meeting between psychology and mysticism begins not with an answer, but with the recognition that two very different traditions have noticed something important — without necessarily having noticed the same thing.


References

Buchtova, M., Malinakova, K., van Dijk, J. P., Husek, V., & Tavel, P. (2024). Sensory processing sensitivity is associated with religiosity and spirituality. Humanities and Social Sciences Communications, 11, 244.

Greven, C. U., Trupp, M. D., Homberg, J. R., & Slagter, H. A. (2026). Sensory processing sensitivity: Theory, evidence, and directions. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 30(6), 530–545.

Malinakova, K., Vyvleckova, L., & Novak, L. (2024). Religiosity/spirituality and mental health: The moderating role of sensory processing sensitivity. Humanities and Social Sciences Communications, 11, 1672.

Roxburgh, E. C., Vernon, D., & Schofield, M. B. (2024). Sensory processing sensitivity, transliminality, and boundary-thinness as predictors of anomalous experiences, beliefs, and abilities. Current Psychology, 43, 30098–30106.

John of the Cross. Dark Night of the Soul, especially Book I, chapters 8–9. In K. Kavanaugh & O. Rodriguez (trans.), The Collected Works of St. John of the Cross. ICS Publications.

Teresa of Ávila – The Interior Castle & her Autobiography 

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Guilt, Conditioning, and the Dark Night of the Soul

Dark Night of the Soul Symptoms: Common Inner Experiences

The Sacred Value of Being Alone: Solitude in the Dark Night of the Soul